
This season looked to be the one to finally conclude the near decade-long drought of Eastern Conference all-star benches lacking a New York representative. David Lee, prior to the Janury 28 game vs. Toronto) has averaged 19.4 points per game, 11.4 rebounds per game, 3.4 assists per game, and is shooting with a percentage of 55.4%, all while playing as a 6 foot-9 inch center. His jumpshot now extends to about 20 feet out and for lack of a better term, is pure money. The game is seemingly just too easy for Lee this season, as he is emerging as a dominant force in the league.
Are these the qualities of an all-star? According to the NBA head coaches, no. Al Horford of the Hawks managed to squeak in as the last forward reserve in the east. Horford is averaging 13.6 points per game, 9.8 rebounds per game, 2.2 assists per game, and shooting at 57%.
But the difference in votes to the trip to Dallas next month depended on one element: the standings. The Hawks sit among the elite in the east at third place, behind powerhouses Cleveland and Boston. The Knicks, however, entering Thursday's game, appear at 10th place, 4 games behind Charlotte for the eighth and final playoff seed.
David Lee is one of the finest forwards in the eastern conference, no question. His team however, doesn't particularly share that same success. This fact alone is what kept Lee from appearing in the first All-Star Game of his career, and the first for a Knick in nine.. yes.. nine years. Do the Knicks, their fans, and Lee himself have a legitimate gripe with the final selections? Sure they do. But is the reasoning that supports the voters' decisions wrong in any way? Not at all.
There is one major flaw in not only NBA all-star voting, but in other sports as well. Fans vote for all-star starters, and their (or should I say, our) vote counts 100%. The players, coaches, and the league have absolutely zero say as to who starts in the game. The result of this defect in the voting system is what we are all afraid of, and fears have turned into reality in 2010. Allen Iverson, who started the season in Memphis, played three games there, half-heartedly announced his retirement after Donnie Walsh and the Knicks didn't want to put player-development at risk for the sake of signing him, then returned to the city he called home for a decade, and is currently averaging the lowest numbers of his entire career, has not just made, but is starting the All-Star Game at the point for the East. An all-star roster spot that so many well-deserving players yearn to call theirs, is being held hostage by a 34 year-old point guard, averaging 14 and 4.
But what do I know? I'm just another fan, right? Not according to the NBA, (along with the MLB and NHL) who believes my peers and I deserve the right to determine the best players in the league.